Fresno Criminal Defense Attorney | Fresno DUI Attorney Serving all of California

        Avvo
Call for a free case evaluation.
559.441.1418

Contact Us

Send us a quick email

Please type your full name.
Invalid email address.
Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Enter Code
Invalid Input

This article is a contineunce of previous articles regarding Driving Under the Influence and some of the Field Sobriety test and other factor the police will take into consideration before they make an arrest.  As stated in earlier articles if you have any questions if you were pulled over by an officer or arrested for Driving Under the Influence give me a call. 559-441-1418.  I can help you through the process and have handled many hundreds of DUI cases both prosecuting and defending.  I have the knowlege to understand when an officer may have made a mistake in the paperwork or procedure in the process of your DUI. 

 

I will now look at some of the other tests that will be administered that are supposed to administered in a particular way.

WALK AND RUN TEST

The walk and run test that attempts to assess the same characteristics that a person need to safely drive a car. 

The original research for this test shows that it is only 68% accurate in determining if a person bac is .10 or higher.

 

The walk and run test should be conducted on a reasonably dry, hard, level, nonslippery surface.  There should be sufficient room for subjects to complete nine heel to toe steps.

Officers are trained that the original research indicated that individuals over 65 years of age or people with back, leg, inner ear problems had difficulty performing this test. 

NHTSA has identifiied the following conditions that may interfere with a persons performance on the Walk and Turn test. 

1. Weather conditions

2. Subjects age

3. Subjects footwear

people wearing heels more than 2 inches high should be given the oppurtunity to remove their shoes.

Subjects with any form of unusual footwear should be afforded the oppurtunity to remove the footwear prior to the test.

For standardization in the performance of this test.  Have the subject assume the heel to toe stance by giving the following verbal instructions, accompanied by demonstrations.

Place your left foot on the line (real or imaginary)

Place your right foot on the line ahead of the left foot, with the heel of your right foot against the toe of the left foot.

Place your arms down at your sides.

Maintain this position until I have completed the instructions do not start to walk until told to do so.

Do you understand the instructions so far? make sure the subject undertands the instructions)

Explain the test requirements by giving instructions, accompanied by demonstrations.

When I tell you to start, take nine heel to toe steps on the line, turn, and take nine heel to toe steps down the line.

 

In our next Post we will continue with this test and explain how it goes into an overall assesment the officer is supposed to make in determining whehter to make an arrest. 

This article is a continuation of the earlier articles regarding Driving Under the Influence and the tests and requrements that police need before making an arrest.  I left off the previous article on the Nystagmus tests and the things an officer will be looking for when conducting these tests.

 

I left off wiht step Six

here is step 7.

Check the right and left eye for the "Distinct and Sustained Nystagmus at Maximum Deviation clue"

If the jerkiness is distinct and sustained that is one clue.

Once again the position the stimulas approximately 12-15 inches in front of the subjects nose and slightly above eye level. 

Move the sitmulas off to the right side (checking the subjects left eye) untle the eyes have gone as far as possible

Hold the stimulas steady at that position for a minumum of fourt (4) seconds, and carefully watch eye. 

Then move the stimulas back across the subjects face all the way out to the left side.  (subjects right eye)

Hold the stimulas steady steady and carefully watch they eye. 

If the person is impaired, they eye is likely to exhibit definite, distinct and sustained jerking when hield at maximum deviation for a minumum of four seconds.  In order to "count" this clue as evidence of impairment, the nystagmus must be distinct and sustained for a minimum of four seconds. 

each eyes should be checked twice for this clue. 

ENDPOINT NYSTAGMUS

The jerking of the eyes that occurs when they are brought out as far to the side as possible.  Most unimpared people people exhibit Endpoint Nystagmus.

FATIGUE NYSTAGMUS

This type of Nystagmus may occur if a persons eyes are held at maximum deviation for more than 30 seconds. 

Step 8 Onset of Nystagmus prior to 45 degrees. 

The stimulus is a positioned approximately 12-15 inches from the subjects nose and slightly above eye level.  It is necessary to move the stimulas slowly to identify the point at which the eye begins to jerk. 

Start moving the stimulus towards the right side (left eye) at a speed that would take approximtely 4 seconds for the stimulus to reach the edge of the subjects shoulder. 

As you slowly move the stimulus, watch the eye carefully for any sign of jerking.  When you see the jerking begin, immediately stop moving the stimulus and hold it steady at that posiiton. 

With the stimulus held steady look at the eye and verify that the jerking is continuing.  If the jerking is not evident with the stimulus held steady you have not located the point of onset.  Therefore, resume moving the stimulus slowly toward the side until you notice the jerking begin.

When you locate the point of onset Nystagmus you must determine whether it is prior to 45 degrees. 

Veriy that some white is still moving in the corner of the eye.

Examine the aglignment between the stimulus and the edge of the subjects shoulder.

Repeat the process of the subjects right eye. 

Each eye should be checked twice for this clue.

Step 9 total the clues

Maximum number of clues possible for each eye: 3

Total Maximum number of clues possible for both eyes 6. 

Step 10.  Check for vertical Nystagmus

Postion the stimulus horizontally about 12-15 inches in front of the subjects nose. 

Instruct the subject to hold the head still, and follow the eobject with the eyes only. 

Raise the object until the subjects eyes are elevated as far as possible

Hold for a minimum of four seconds. 

Watch closely  for evidence of they eyes jerking upward. 

For VGN to be recorded.  It must be distinct and sustained for a minimum of four seconds at maximum elevation. 

VGN may be present in subjects under the influence of high doses of alcohol for that individual or some other drugs. 

This article will be continued  

This article is a continuation of earlier articles that have went through DUI arrest from the time of the pullover until the time of the arrest and further.

earlier we went through the pullover some ot the signs of a person being under the influence and some of the objective symptoms. 

Also, we touched on the preliminary test and the non standardized versus standardized testing.  we continue that below.

ONSET OF NYSTAGMUS PRIOR TO 45 DEGREES (CLUE NUMBER THREE) This clue is present if a person eyes start to jerk before they reach 45 degrees.  Officers are trained to estimate 45 degrees two different ways. 

Using 15 square template that is cut diagnally.

Approximately equel to the edge of a person's shoulders

DRE qeustions using formula to prove BAC between .00 and .05%

Officers are trained that the three Standardized Field Sobriety elements are as followed:

1. Standardized Administrative Procedures

2. Standardized Clues

3. Standardized Criteria

 

Stanndardized Field Sobriety Tests Setup Questions.

 

SPECIFIC PROCEDURES FOR THE HGN TEST

Step 1 Check for eyeglasses Instruct subject to remove eyeglasses

Step 2 Vertical Instructions

put feet together hands at the side

keep the head still

look for stimulas

follow movement of the stimulas with eyes only

keep looking for the stimulas until the test is over

Step 3 Position the stimulas Position the stimulas approximately 12-15 inches in front of the subjects nose and slightly above eye level to commence the test

 

Resting Nystagmus may be observed at the time.  Officers should note whether the subject displays Resting Nystagmus.

Step 4 Equel Pupil Size and Resting Nystagmus.

Step 5 Check for equel tracking.  The speed of the stimulas should be approximately same speed used as checking for the lack of smooth pursuit.  Make at least two complete passes in front of the eyes. There should be at least two complete passes in front of the eyes.  There should be a clear distinguishable break between the check for equel tracking and lack of smooth pursuit.

If a person has unequel pupil size resting nystagmus or unequel tracking it suggests the person is likely to have medical conditions or injuries that would cause nystagmus to be present.  Some seizure medications also cause nystgmus. 

If  a person has an obvious eye condition such as an artificial eye. the HGN test should not be administered. 

STEP 6 LACK OF SMOOTH PURSUIT

It is necessary to move the object smoothly in order to check the eyes ability to pusue smoothly. the stimulas should be moved from center postiion.  all the way back across the subjects face all the way out to the left side where the eye can go no further (checking the subjects right eye) and then go back to the center. 

The object must be moved steadily at a speed that takes approximately 2 seconds to bring eye from center to side. 

In checking this clue make at least two complete passes in front of they eyes. 

STEP 7

Check the right and left eye for the "Distinct and Sustained Nystagmus at Maximum Deviation" clue.  If the jerkiness is distinct and sustained  that is one clue.

 

Next blog post we will continue on the factors that the officer must take into consideration before making an arrest for Driving Under the influence after that blog post we will take a break from the factors in determining whether to arrest for DUI and will look at other issues in the law including Not Guilty by reason of Insanity Law.

I will continue on today with some of the factors to consider in a dui case, and some of the test the police use.  I  will continue with some of the test the police will use to determine if there is probable cause to arrest somoene for DUI. 

POST ROTATIONIAL NYSTAGMUS

NYSTAGMUS is closely related to rotational nystagmus when the person stops spinning, the fluid in the inner ear remains disturbed for a period of time, and the eyes continue to jerk.  This could be observed in a person after a rollover accident.  or spin out.

 

POSITIONAL ALCOHOL NYSTAGMUS

occurs when a foreign fluid such as alchol that alters the specific gravity of the blood in unequel concentrations in the blood and the vesitbular system.  This  causes the vestibular system to respond to gravity in certain positions, resulting in nystagmus.

 

PAN I occurs when the inner ear alcohol concentration in the blood is greater than the inner fluid.  PAN occurs while the BAC is increasing. 

PAN II occurs when the alcohol concentration in the inner ear.  This occurs while the BAC is decreasing. 

 

NEURAL NYSTAGMUS

Optokinetic Nystagmus occurs when the eyes fixate on an object that suddenly moves out of sight, or when the eyes watch sharply contrasting moving images.

 

Examples include watching strobe strobe lights, rotating lights, or rapidly moving traffic.

Physiosocial Nystagmus is a natural nystagmus that keeps the sensory cells of the eye from tiring.  This is the most common type of Nystagmus this produces extremely minor jerks of the eyes. 

Natural Nystagmus

Gaze Nystagmus is a form of nystagmus that occurs when the eyes attempt to maintain visual fixation on a stimulas. Horizontal, vertical, and resting nystagmus are three forms.

Pathological Disorders

Nystagmus can also be caused by patholigical disorders.  They include brain tumors and other brain damage and some diseases of the inner ear. 

 

Certain medical conditions may also cause nystagmus to be present. 

Officers are trained to look for a total of six clues on the HGN test.  The officer looks for the same three clues in each eye.  If four or more clues are observed the test meet the criterion and or is a failure of the test.

 

A look of smooth pursuit clue number one.  this clue is present if the eyes jerk or bounce as they follow smoothly moving stimulas.

Distinct and sustained nystagmus at maximum deveation clue number 2 this clue is evident if the eye is held at maximum deviation of four seconds and continues to jerk toward the side some people exhibit jerking of the eye at maximum deviation even they are not imparied. 

Difference between Distinct Nystagmus and Distinct and Sustained Nystagmus at Maximum Deviation Questions. 

In the next article I will continue wiht a discussion of the tests to determine if someone is unde the influence while driving.

This article is a continuence of my earlier articles on Driving Under the Influence offense in Fresno ca and other parts of California.  As a Former Probation Officer DA and a Criminal Defense Attorney with more than 14 years of experience I have the knowlege to properly represent you in your criminal case or DUI case.  I have both the experience of prosecuting and defending DUI cases.  If after reading this blog bost or others you need help don't hesitate to call 559 441-1418. 

  In my earlier blog post I went over the non standardized testing to determine if there is probable cause to arrest for a Driving Under the Infuence. 

THE EXIT SEQUENCE

When an officer asks a driver to exit a vehicle, the officer is trained to look for the following additional specific signs of impairment.

Angry

unusual instructions

cant open the door

leaves car in gear

climbs out car

leans against car

keeps hands on car

PHASE THREE- PRE ARREST SCREENING

Officers administer the three psychological field sobriety tests.  Psychological tests are methods of assessing a persons mental (psychological) and physical impairment.  Most psychological tests use the concept of divided attention to assess a persons impairment. 

Field sobriety tests that simulate the divided attention characteristics of driving have been developed and are being used by law enforcement agencies nationwide. 

These tests attempt to simulate the same mental and physical capabilities that a person needs to drive safely. 

information processing

short term memory

judgment and decision making

balance

steady sure reactions

clear vision

small muscle control

coordination of limbs

 

THE NATIONAL TRAFFIC SAFETY ADMINISTRATION (NHTSA) PROTOCAL

The three Standardized Field Sobriety Tests tha tthe police use are the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test, the Walk and Turn Test, and the One Leg Stand Test. 

The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test is administered first.  This test is considered to be the most reliable of the three standardized tests the police are  trained to do.  The police are trained that it is 77 percent accurate for people above the level of .10. 

Nystagmus is defined by the involuntary jerking of the eyes.  Nystagmus is a natural and and normal phenomenon.  Alcohol and certain drugs do not cause this effect.  They merely exaggerate or or magnify the effect. 

There are over 40 different kinds of Nystagmus and many of them look the same as the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus that the police are looking for as evidence of impairment.

The police are not trained to distinguish between different kinds of Nystagmus.  However, some officers will testify that they are. 

it is common for the officer to misdiagnose some other form of bystagmus.  Call it Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus, and use it as evidence against a  person.

 

There are three general categories of Nystagmus:

Vestibular

Neural

Pathological Disorders and Disease. 

Vestibular Nystagmus

Vestibular Nystagmus is caused by the movement of or action of the vestibular (inner ear)  system. 

Rotational Nystagmus occurs when a person is spun around or rotated rapidly, causing the fluid in the inner ear to be disturbed.  If it were possible to observe eyes of a rotating person, they would be seen to jerk noticeably. 

 

Post rotational

nystagmus is a closely related to rotational nystagmus when the person stops spinning the fluid in the inner ear remains disturbed for a period of time. , and the eyes continue to jerk.  This could be observed in a person after a rollover accident or a spin out. 

caloric

nystagmus occurs when the fluid motion in the cannals of the vesibular system is stimulated by temperature (cold in one ear and warm in another). 

positional alcohol nystagmus (pan) occurs when a foreign fluid such as alcohol that alters the specific gravity of the blood is unequel concentrations in the blood and vestibular systems. 

 

This article will be an extension of the earlier articles that I have written regarding DUI's.  At the Law office of Gerald Schwab.  I represent People not cases the reason I do this job is to help people get through what could possibly be the worse days of there lives.  After being arrested you will have many questions you need experienced counsel.  I have both prosecuted and defended DUI case in Fresno and severl other couties including Madera, Fresno, Tulare, Merced, Monterey, and many more.

With a DUI case the main thing you are looking at is wether the proper paperwork and procedure was used, for the DUI arrest. 

 

TO GAIN EVIDENCE

To gain evidence, officers are trained to use three questioning tactics while the driver is still behind the wheel.  These tactics are:

1. Asking for two things simeltaneously

2. Asking interrupting or distracting questions

3. Asking unusual questions

 

These tactics are based upon the concept of divided attention.  They require the driver to concentrate on two or more things at the same time.  When an officer asks for two things simultaneously he might ask the driver to produce both his drivers license and the vehicle registration. 

The officer is then trained to look for the following evidence of impairmen

forgets to produce both documents

produces documents other than the ones requested

fails to see the license, registration or both while securing them

fumbles or drops the wallet, purse, license, or registration

is unable to retrieve documents within fingertips.

 

When an officer asks interrupting or distracting questions he might attempt to divide the drivers attention between searching for the license or registration and answering a new question. 

While the driver is responding to the request for license registration or both you ask unrelated questions "What days is it" or "Where are you coming from"

The officer is then trained to look for the following evidence of impairment. 

ignoring the question and concentrates only on license or registration search

forgets to resume the search after answering question

supplies a grossly incorrect answer

When an officer asks unusual qeustions it is employed after you have obtained the drivers license and registration

For example while holding the drivers license the officer might ask what is  your middle  name. 

There are many such questions which the driver mormally would be able answer quickly and easily but which might prove difficult if the driver is impaired, simply because they are unusual questions. 

 

For example a driver may respond to the question about the middle name by giving a first name.

NON STANDARDIZED SOBRIETY TEST

There are three non-standardized sobriety test that an officer may ask a driver to perform prior to performing the standardized field sobriety test. 

Alphabet the driver is required to recite part of the alphabet.  The driver is instructed to begin with a letter other than A and stop at a letter other than Z.  This divides the drivers attention becuase he must concentrate to begin at an unusual starting point and remember where to stop. 

Count Down

The driver is asked to count out loud 15 or more numbers in reverse sequence.  For example, the driver might be told to "count out loud backwards.  Starting with the number 68 and ending with the number 53. 

Finger Count

The driver is asked to touch the the tip of the thumb to the tip of each finger on the same hand while simeltaneously counting up to one two three four then to reverse the direction on the fingers while simaltaneously counting down four three two one this is another divided attention task

I will continue in my next post on this subject.

Schwab photo

Gerald Schwab, Jr.

CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY & DUI ATTORNEY SERVING ALL OF CALIFORNIA

Schedule a Free
Case Evaluation

Law Office of Gerald Schwab, Jr.
Fresno Criminal Defense Attorney
5588 N Palm Ave,
Fresno, CA 93704
View Map
Phone: 559.441.1418 
Website: